Wednesday, October 27, 2010

DEATH IN VENICE

Inspired from an actual event in Thomas Mann's life, the novel like any of his works deals with the themes of conflict of polarities, homoeroticism, conception of art and the artist and psycho-analysis of protagonist. Characterized by excessive usage of symbols and leitmotif, along with intense language and ominous title creates morbid atmosphere and prepare us for tragic event in the novel. Novel involves philosophical examination of the ideas and protagonist, undertaken in a detached ironic tone

SUMMARY:

Gustav von Aschenbach is an aging German writer of fastidious self-discipline who believes that true art is produced only in "defiant despite" of corrupting passions and physical weaknesses.

When Aschenbach has the urge to travel, he makes subsequent trip to Venice which is the first indulgence he has allowed himself in years as he believes that he might find artistic inspiration from a change of scene. Aschenbach allows the weary Venetian atmosphere and gently rocking gondolas to lull him into a defenseless state. At his hotel he notices an extremely beautiful fourteen-year-old Polish boy named Tadzio, who is visiting with his mother, sisters, and governess. Initially, Aschenbach's has only aesthetic interest in the boy and believed that boy will act as source of inspiration for completing his work.

Aschenbach spends days on end watching Tadzio play on the beach, even following his family around the streets of Venice. Cholera cripples the city, and although the authorities try to conceal the danger from the tourists, Aschenbach soon learns the facts about the fatal epidemic. Since, he cannot bear to leave Tadzio so he stays on in Venice. He becomes progressively daring in his obsession of the boy, gradually becoming more and more demeaned, until he finally dies of the cholera, degraded, and a slave to his passions, stripped of his dignity.

THEMES:

At the opening of the novel, Gustav von Aschenbach, while possessing a latent sensuality, exists as a man who has always held his passions in check, never allowing them expression either in his life or in his art. Aschenbach is in a state of such imbalance that could not long remain stable, nor could it produce truly inspired art. However, having kept his passions under such tight control for so long, once Aschenbach begins to let down his guard against them, they rise up in redoubled force and take over his life. Once Aschenbach admits sensual beauty into his life, represented by the boy Tadzio, all of his moral standards break down, and he becomes a slave to beauty, a slave to desire; he becomes degraded. Thus, Aschenbach undergoes a total displacement from one extreme of art to other, from austere form to sensual form, from apollonian nature to Dionysus nature. Thomas Mann believed that both extremes are dangerous which is shown through the character of Aschenbach. When he repressed his desires, he was physically weak and when he gave way to his passions, he died. Mann believed that art that art that is not genuine, deceitful and meant to conceal truth is artificial and will do no good.

Aschenbach love for boy is highly obsessive: he is satisfied by just watching the boy playing, following him through streets of Venice even being aware that boy is not aware of his love. Even the threat of imminent death, he is ready to stay in Venice for the boy.

The story is highly symbolic in nature like Aschenbach’s psychological repression stands as a symbol for bourgeois Europe’s repression, his death symbolizes death of old hierarchy in coming war, cholera infecting Venice symbolizes illness in Aschenbach’s mind, red color represent passion and many other. Venice like Aschenbach stood upright with great effort built on lagoon but is moving back into sea similar to his degradation.

Novel is semiautobiographical – Thomas Mann also ‘suffered’ from homoerotic feelings, fell in love with a Polish boy in Venice in 1905 when he felt similar restlessness as by author.


Thomas Mann didn’t wasted a word, every minute detail is presented beautifully. To fully grasp the meaning and appreciate the work, at least two readings are required.


By:

Vishal Verma

2009CS10224

6 comments:

  1. Vishal how would you interpret Tadzio's reaction to all the attention he is getting? As mentioned at several places in the novel; he knows that Aschenbach is watching him; but he neither attempts to approach Aschenbach nor tries to avoid him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Manik, I believe that Tanzio knew that Aschenbach was following and watching him but he never knew about the homosexual feeling of Aschenbach as to why he was following him. Also, since he is young boy just 14 years old, he is too gullible to understand or to guess the reason for Aschenbach's obsession for him. Also since there is age difference between the two people, so Tanzio might have thought that he may resemble his child or anything of that sort. Maybe Tanzio may have developed some kind of affinity for him and was hesitant to confront him. Although his governess was alarmed by Aschenbach's following Tanzio so she tried to persuade Tanzio to remain away from him.

    ReplyDelete
  3. well said Vishal.. i have a few things which i would like to bring up; one of them being the power of the narrative of this book. The way in which the narrative builds up a forbiding and suffocating atmosphere. The tension and the passion of Aschenbach are tangible. Another quite prominent thing is that the way in which the stark contrast between the condition of Aschenbach initially in the begining of the book; and towards the end when he is sitting in a market place hallucinating; having chased Tadzio through the streets of venice. The complete and utter breakdown of mental balance and the stringent dicipline is clear.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes, I said in the review that this novel incorporated mythical elements inside the novel, which along with intense narrative and excessive use of symbol creates highly ominous atmosphere signaling some tragic event in subsequent sections.
    About hallucination, I would say that in the end because of his suffering of cholera and his mental-breakdown, he was hallucinating. He underwent mental-breakdown as he his temptation which rose with tremendous forces and took over his mind. He was not able to think logically and wisely, the way he used to think before his first indulgence that is visiting Venice. He took to deceitful art which shows fall of his mental standards.
    That's nice you noticed this think.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete